4077 Shares

What does it mean to write a history paper in historical context?

What does it mean to write a history paper in historical context? Topic: Present writing paper
June 26, 2019 / By Mattaniah
Question: my teacher is making us read poland by james michner and he says on the paper "your assighnment is to write a short history of one of the families in the book within the historical context presented"
Best Answer

Best Answers: What does it mean to write a history paper in historical context?

Joab Joab | 4 days ago
Maybe an example will also help. Let's say you are writing about Christopher Columbus. Most people today see him as little more than an adventurer out for money and power who ultimately decimated the native population where he landed. However, people of HIS time didn't see it quite that way. They thought he was very brave and that natives were not "people" in the sense that they were -- so perhaps what he did was good and not bad. Now, in our more "enlightened" modern world (or that's how we like to think of ourselves) -- Columbus' values are skewed. But in HIS world, they were the values everyone else held. So, if you wrote about Columbus in the historical context in which HE lived, you would use the moral standing of HIS culture and time period. Hope that helped -- this is a difficult concept as it is hard to get past OUR historical context!
👍 96 | 👎 4
Did you like the answer? What does it mean to write a history paper in historical context? Share with your friends

We found more questions related to the topic: Present writing paper


Joab Originally Answered: How and when was buddhism created? What was the historical context?
There are three main branches of BuddhIsm - Mahayana, Theravada, Vajrayana IN A NUTSHELL HERE IS BASIC BUDDHISM - Buddhism was supposedly created by "The Buddha" after witnessing four sights he found profoundly mindblowing. - It was probably created in Nepal or India Monuments, temples, and art that focuses the mind to unleash its potential were constructed to help reach the path of enlightenment. Buddhism had a profound effect on East Asia (China, Korea, Japan) - that requires extra research Buddhism have 5 great vows - Do not steal, do not kill, be sexually modest, do not be posessive, and do not take intoxicants that lead to loss of mindfulness. Helping others is also high priority. Women in Buddhism, much like many other religions weren't given full privilige. However int he Mahayana branch of Buddhism, women were allowed to become priests.
Joab Originally Answered: How and when was buddhism created? What was the historical context?
Buddhism was created while Sidatha Guatima (hope i spelled that correctly) was alive. His path one to find the true meaning of life. Its more a path to Buddhahood that anyone can achieve through the 8 wheel path. (Again its been a couple years since ive studied buddhism sorry). But it was created through his beliefs and by his followers while he was alive in his quest for achieve true enlightenment. It was created in India. Well the practice from what I understand is to let go of all things that are trivial, live a simple life of mediation avoidance. Avoiding things like money, cars, greed, sex exc......
Joab Originally Answered: How and when was buddhism created? What was the historical context?
Buddhism doesn t say something to non buddhists on the subject. even although, if somebody is a Buddhist and that they desire to stick to That relion, it style of feels from what I study that the entire foundation of Homosexuality is in temperate, Homosexuality is the foundation for the gay or lesbian s entire identity. that could desire to seem antithetical to Buddhism. no longer something could be the entire foundation of your identity. i could desire to be incorrect yet it quite is attachment. (working example, there s no hetero sexual chiors or channels or newspapers, yet there are those issues all in step with gay identity and that s why i think of it s incompatible with Buddhist teachings. They don t say lots approximately it, because of the fact speaking approximately it creates extra attachment.

Gordon Gordon
It's tough. You can't use what we know today to judge the people's actions. That would be using a "modern" context. You try to enter their world. Approach their problems in view of what they knew and what tools they had. Keep it short. Later you will learn from your teacher's remarks if you understood exactly what she wanted.
👍 30 | 👎 3

Gordon Originally Answered: What is meant by the historical context of a painting?
cultural context means, for example, a color has different meaning in different cultures (white in one part of the world is appropriate for wedding, in another part of the world it's the color for funeral). same thing with historical context. the (symbolic) meaning of things depends on the period of time. a Rubens painting for instance reflects the beauty of voluptuous women, whereas nowadays we consider them fat (in a bad way). by the way there's a cultural context here too: some parts of the world still consider big women beautiful (good for them!). but I don't have the answer to your question. maybe it's about the knowledge of stars, what they really are. in Van Gogh's lifetime science didn't know very much about the origin of stars. now we know that the stars we see at night are actually dead. but I doubt this has anything to do with the historical context of The Starry Night: the feeling you get from looking at the stars is probably the same in our time and Van Gogh's. so maybe the answer is: the historical context is irrelevant. it's a human thing to be amazed by stars (any kind, for that matter).
Gordon Originally Answered: What is meant by the historical context of a painting?
Starry Night was painted during the day, from memory of the view he had at night. It has been the subject of many other pieces of art ever since including Don McLeans song 'Starry Starry Night' (I really do like that song!) Painted whilst in the asylum, The Starry Night is believed to be one of van Goghs' greatest works. As for the historical context, I can only imagine it to be as follows; An observation of the night sky, is it different to how we see it in present day. The circumstances in which van Gogh observed the sky; ie, through the window of an asylum. Its place in the art world of its time, its importance as a piece of work. How was it recieved by the critics upon it's arrival. How is it represened in the era - it is usual, groundbreaking, significant etc. Was the institution tolerant of his painting. or, it could be far more base than all of that. For instance; Where did he get his canvasses, paint, brushes. Could he afford the best. How quick was delivery (not 24hrs!). Did he make his own materials or did his brother Theo send them. If so, how and when. The questions go on and on and so I suppose you have to choose a path of dicovery and stick with that one.

If you have your own answer to the question present writing paper, then you can write your own version, using the form below for an extended answer.